You are reading

Shut Down Rikers Island–And Don’t Build New Jails–Immigrant Groups Say

(Jimmy Van Bramer: Twitter)

Oct 9, 2019 By Shane O’Brien

A number of immigration organizations and some elected officials are holding three days of rallies across Queens and Brooklyn in opposition to the mayor’s borough-based jail plan.

The groups–as well as elected officials such as Council Member Jimmy Van Bramer- are calling for the closure of Rikers Island but without the construction of new jails. They argue this can be done by reducing the prison population from about 7,000 today to 3,000 by 2026 through justice reform.

The city, however, only has room for 2,100 prisoners in its jails outside Rikers Island.

The rallies started on Wednesday in Jackson Heights and will conclude in Brooklyn on Friday.

Wednesday’s rally took place at Diversity Plaza in Jackson Heights, while Thursday’s rally will take place at 5 p.m. at the intersection of Lefferts Boulevard and Liberty Avenue in Richmond Hill.

The final rally will take place Friday at 2:30 p.m. at Avenue C Plaza in Kensington, Brooklyn.

The Jackson Heights rally was attended by Council Member Jimmy Van Bramer and immigrant advocacy groups Desis Rising Up & Moving (DRUM), Immigrant Defense Project and Detention Watch Network among other organizations.

Thursday’s rally will be attended by Council Member Inez Barron, while Brooklyn Council Member Alicka Ampry-Samuel is slated to attend Friday’s rally.

DRUM is holding the rallies ahead of next week’s City Council vote on the mayor’s plan to shut Rikers Island and replace it with four borough-based jails in Queens, Brooklyn, Manhattan and the Bronx. The plan will cost about $11 billion.

The City Council vote is essentially the last step in the process, via ULURP, before the mayor’s plan is officially approved.

On Wednesday, the protest group argued that no jails are necessary in order to close Rikers since the city’s jail population is falling.

They said that the money would be better spent on improving schools, fixing public housing and the subways, creating job programs and providing more care for physical and mental illnesses.

The protest groups also contend that any new jails would put immigrant communities at a greater risk of being detained and deported.

Van Bramer took to Twitter after the rally and reiterated his opposition to the new jail plan.

“We should not be pouring $10 billion back into a failed, racist system that criminalizes poverty & thrives on terrorizing immigrant communities,” Van Bramer said on Twitter.

Last week, Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez took a similar stance and said that Rikers could be closed without any new jails being built.

She endorsed a report from advocacy group No New Jails, which says the city can reduce its jail population to 3,000 by 2026 and house inmates in the current correctional facilities in Manhattan, Brooklyn and the Bronx.

However, the city said that the No New Jails concept is implausible. The mayor’s office forecasts that there will be around 4,000 inmates in New York by 2026 and that there are only 2,100 beds in the current borough jails – 900 less than the population No New Jails forecasted and just over half of what the city predicts.

The mayor’s office said that it was not possible to close Rikers without building new jails and said that Rikers would remain open if no new jails are built.

email the author:


Click for Comments 
Why did Trump completely failed to deliver his central campaign promise?

I thought Trump pretended he was building a wall? Wasn’t there that little tantrum where he shut down the government?

Now the taxpayer has to shoulder the burden from Trump’s open borders.

Trumps open borders???

I am pretty sure the left in this country is advocating for open borders..not Trump. Remember all the Dems calling him a racist for trying to close off the border? I also remember clearly the Dems refusing to fund the wall in the congressional budget….that comment is just bizarre (also see Dem presidential candidates promising free healthcare to illegals)….that is what is causing taxpayers to shoulder the burden

Remember when he pretended Mexico would make a "one-time payment" for the wall?

He obviously doesn’t have the leadership qualities to get the wall built. Even the Trump Shutdown was a failure. Sad!


New Yorkers don’t want Amazon to be here , and they want to close Rikers Island ? .
It’s like the Twilight Zone .
DeBlasio, A.O.C and all the others is causing chaos.
When the recession hits NYC is going to be crazy ?

what goes around....

I cant wait until crime goes thru the roof here when the recession comes and all these clowns start complaining crime on the streets is out of control and blame systemic racism instead of their own moronic plan to close all the jails…what an embarrassment that we let all these losers have a voice in our society…if they are so smart and their policies so good and just, why are the countries they come from disgusting places that i wouldn’t let my dog live?? let the people who built our society and western culture continue their thousands of years of success without third world logic mucking up our quality of life.. you people are first generation in shoes…please shut up or we will have to push back..Trump was just a goof..we are starting to lose our patience…Thank you in advance

nom de plum

Is it true that the City/DiBlasio want to make Rikers Island a resort island for hotels and make a lot of money!!!!


Leave a Comment
Reply to this Comment

All comments are subject to moderation before being posted.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Recent News

AG’s office launches investigation into NYPD-involved fatal shooting near Roosevelt Avenue in Corona on Saturday morning

The New York Attorney General’s Office of Special Investigation (OSI) has launched a probe into the death of Jesus Alberto Nunez Reyes, 65, who was shot and killed during an encounter with NYPD officers in Corona on Saturday morning.

At approximately 4:09 a.m. on April 20, police officers responded to 39-21 103rd St., where they encountered Nunez Reyes allegedly holding a knife. The officers repeatedly commanded him to drop the knife, but Nunez Reyes did not comply, and an officer fired at him, the AG’s office said in a brief statement. Nunez Reyes was rushed to Elmhurst Hospital, where he was later pronounced dead. Officers recovered a knife at the scene.